"Abstract
This paper provides a theoretical framework to explain recent empirical findings on the malleability of morality, and suggest new testable implications. Building on a basic model with image concerns, we introduce the concept of narratives that allow individuals to maintain a positive image when in fact acting in a morally questionable way. We show how narratives, however feeble, inhibit moral behavior in downplaying externalities, magnifying the cost of moral behavior, or in suggesting not being pivotal. We further show that narratives spread virally when negative, but not when positive. We then turn to imperatives, i.e., moral rules or precepts, as a mode of communication to persuade agents to behave morally, and identify the conditions under which Kantian behavior will emerge in an otherwise fully utilitarian environment. We also show how an unwillingness to engage in trade-offs can arise, with implications for the elicitation of moral preferences. Finally, we study how collective decision making and organizational design produces a sub-additivity of responsibility."
Wednesday, June 13, 2018
Even Nobel prize winning economists are talking about narratives
See Narratives, Imperatives and Moral Reasoning by Armin Falk and 2014 Nobel economics winner Jean Tirole.
Sunday, April 29, 2018
Moralizing gods help societies cooperate
See Why You Just Helped That Stranger by Robert M. Sapolsky. According to Wikipedia, "He is currently a professor of biology, and professor of neurology and neurological sciences and, by courtesy, neurosurgery, at Stanford University." Cooperation may be important for economies. How do you get a large number of people in a factory to work together, for example? Excerpts:
"When do religions tend to invent such moralizing gods? A number of researchers—such as Carlos A. Botero of Washington University in St. Louis and his colleagues—have shown that moralizing gods become more common in large-group cultures.
Why? Psychologist Ara Norenzayan of the University of British Columbia (UBC), looking at the size of groups, proposes that as cultures grow, something uniquely human emerges—opportunities to act anonymously. To Dr. Norenzayan, that’s when moralizing gods become useful to maintaining the social order. Even if you do something rotten and no one knows, there’s a Someone who does."
"people who play an economic game anonymously, whether they are religious or not, become more pro-social when unconsciously primed to think about God (by having to unscramble jumbled sentences that make religious references)."
"people in cultures with moralizing gods tend to be more pro-social—a hypothesis tested in a recent paper in the journal Nature by psychologist Joe Henrich of UBC and collaborators, including Dr. Norenzayan. The researchers surveyed nearly 600 people around the world, believers in such faiths as Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, animism and ancestor worship.
Subjects had to deal with a simple economic scenario: Here is X amount of money. Divide it between yourself and a geographically distant co-religionist whom you don’t know. Or divide it between that distant co-religionist and a local co-religionist whom you do know. Subjects then answered questions about their religion.
After controlling for various economic and demographic variables, back came a clear answer—the more that people considered their god(s) to be moralizing and punitive, the more generously they divvied up money with that stranger. Thus, the threat of moralizing gods may help to explain some of the human capacity for pro-social cooperation among strangers."
Friday, March 30, 2018
Are we confounding heroism and individualism? Entrepreneurs may not be lone rangers, but they are heroic nonetheless
By Jeffery S. McMullen of Indiana University. March 2017 Business Horizons. The full text of the article is at the link. Here are the last three paragraphs.
"Are entrepreneurs lone rangers? No, but that does not mean that entrepreneurship occurs without heroic individualism. Like entrepreneurship, true heroism is interdependent by its very nature. Even if an entrepreneur were somehow able to go it alone, his or her success would still depend on customers as well as other possible stakeholders (e.g., employees, investors, suppliers, distributors, etc.). Similarly, it is difficult to imagine how anyone could be heroic without a somewhat intimate knowledge of and concern for others’ welfare. Entrepreneurs must bear the costs of their actions before they receive the benefits, which only come if the costs the entrepreneurs incur ultimately benefit someone else.
Therefore, before we declare the heroic entrepreneur a myth, perhaps we should consider the term ‘myth’ as literally as Campbell has. Any innovative act exhibits an element of uncertainty and thus requires a corresponding degree of courage. Although this may only be a moment’s adrenaline rush, it is more likely an extended ride on an emotional rollercoaster that exhausts as well as elates. It is a hero’s journey of existential import and consequence. If this is true, then extraction of heroism from entrepreneurship is misguided, as it would do nothing to correct for scholars’ undersocialization of the entrepreneurial act. Instead, it would merely neglect the courage and sacrifice required from individuals like Elon Musk, who may not act alone, but nonetheless must act if entrepreneurship is to occur.
Ignoring this fact is not only likely to produce bad science but also may affect practice via bad policy. To the extent that policymakers erroneously believe heroism is unnecessary, they are likely to underestimate the costs entrepreneurs must incur not just to succeed, but also to try at all. Lack of sympathy about such sacrifices would likely shape institutional (dis)incentives. Thus, to deny that entrepreneurship is a heroic act is to neglect the need to reward its success and to forgive its potential failure. For these reasons, it may behoove scholars, policymakers, and practitioners alike to think twice before throwing out the baby of heroism with the bathwater of individualism."
Thursday, March 29, 2018
Towards a mythic process philosophy of entrepreneurship
By Lauri J. Laine & Ewald Kibler of Aalto University in Finland. The entire article is at the link.
"Abstract
Drawing on the archetypal theory of the hero's journey, we present an analysis of Stanley Kubrick's 1968 film 2001: A Space Odyssey to theorise on a primordial organisation of entrepreneurial processes. We conclude by discussing opportunities implied by a mythic-process approach in developing new meaning for the ‘beginnings’ and ‘ends’ in the process philosophy of entrepreneurship."
"Highlights
- •
We introduce a mythic process philosophy of entrepreneurship.- •
We connect process philosophy to archetypal theory.- •
We examine Stanley Kubrick’s 1968 film 2001: A Space Odyssey.- •
We theorise on a metaphysical organisation of entrepreneurial processes.- •
We develop meaning for ‘beginnings’ and ‘ends’ in entrepreneuring."
Wednesday, September 27, 2017
Does It Matter If We Call Entrepreneurs Heroes?
Should society call
entrepreneurs heroes? Are they like heroes from mythology? Those may seem like
strange questions for an economist to ask. But they matter for several reasons.
Dwight Lee and Candace Allen argued that if we don't honor entrepreneurial accomplishments,
we won't get enough startups. Deirdre McCloskey says that economic growth only
took off around the year 1800 because the West began according dignity to
entrepreneurs. The work of entrepreneurs parallels the hero's adventure in
mythology. The idea has been gaining attention recently, being discussed in The Wall Street Journal while Jeffery
McMullen has called for scholars to once again take it seriously. Even Joseph
Campbell, the author of The Hero With a
Thousand Faces, one of the inspirations for Star Wars, called the
entrepreneur the real hero in American capitalistic society in a radio
interview (see appendix).
Cyril Morong was the first to examine the similarities
between entrepreneurs and mythological heroes.[i],[ii]
He compared entrepreneurship research to The
Hero With a Thousand Faces to see if the activities of entrepreneurs corresponded
to the hero's adventure. What is the hero's adventure? According to Campbell
"The standard
path of the mythological adventure of the hero is a magnification of the
formula represented in the rites of passage: separation-initiation-return,
which might be named the nuclear unit of the monomyth. A hero ventures forth
from the world of common day into a region of supernatural wonder; fabulous
forces are there encountered and a decisive victory is won; the hero comes back
from this mysterious adventure with the power to bestow boons on his fellow
man."
How is this similar to
the entrepreneur's adventure?
The hero's journey begins with a call to adventure. He or
she is awakened by some herald which touches his or her unconscious world and
creative destiny. The entrepreneur, too, is "called" to the
adventure. By chance, he or she discovers a previously unknown product or way
to make a profit. The lucky discovery cannot be planned and is itself the
herald of the adventure. Israel Kirzner sees successful entrepreneurship as
result of a lucky discovery of a new opportunity for economic profit, but it is
luck that was due to alertness while leading a life of purposeful action.[iii]
The entrepreneur must step out of the ordinary way of
producing and into his or her imagination about the way things could be to
discover the previously undreamt of technique or product. The "fabulous
forces" might be applying the assembly line technique or interchangeable
parts to producing automobiles or building microcomputers in a garage. The
mysterious adventure is the time spent tinkering in research and development.
But once those techniques are discovered or developed, the entrepreneur now has
the power to bestow this boon on the rest of humankind.
Heroes and entrepreneurs both bring change. Campbell
refers to the constant change in the universe as "The Cosmogonic
Cycle" which "unrolls the great vision of the creation and destruction
of the world which is vouchsafed as revelation to the successful hero."
This is similar to Joseph Schumpeter's theory of entrepreneurship called
“creative destruction.” A successful entrepreneur simultaneously destroys and
creates a new world, or at least a new way of life. Henry Ford, for example,
destroyed the horse and buggy age while creating the age of the automobile. The
hero also finds that the world "suffers from a symbolical deficiency"
and "appears on the scene in various forms according to the changing needs
of the race." The changing needs and the deficiency correspond to the
changing market conditions or the changing desires for products. The
entrepreneur is the first person to perceive the changing needs.
Candace Allen and Dwight Lee say that "society needs
heroes" and that "entrepreneurs are heroes in every sense." Yet
they are not often see as heroes-in fact the opposite seems to be true even
though they are indispensable to economic progress. One problem is that
economists have not generally promoted entrepreneurs as being important. They
acknowledge that creative destruction was "the hallmark of
entrepreneurship" without mentioning the parallel to Campbell.
Entrepreneurs are motivated not just by money but also by "service to
something transcendental." Their views
can be summed up with:
“Just as the society that doesn't
venerate winners of races will produce fewer champion runners than the society
that does, the society that does not honor entrepreneurial accomplishment will
find fewer people of ability engaged in wealth creation than the society that
does.”[iv]
Dwight Lee and Candace Allen Smith covered similar ground
in a later article but also used Campbell, notably the
"separation-initiation-return" core of the monomyth (although they
still missed the creation destruction connection between Campbell and
Schumpeter). They suggest that entrepreneurs are seen negatively due to
political biases and the fact that their role in capitalism is poorly
understood.[v]
Calling them heroes might offset this.
Jeffery McMullen argues that seeing entrepreneurs as heroes
doesn't mean that they are hyper-individualistic lone rangers, cutoff from the
rest of society. They may receive some community support, but a new venture
still requires someone to act, to take the first step. This requires courage
due to uncertainty. They are heroic because they bear personal costs. McMullen
also bases his observations on the work of Campbell and Schumpeter. He calls on
scholars to end their hostility to calling entrepreneurs heroes. Otherwise, we
are all "vulnerable to the tyranny of cautious conformity while subjecting
our social systems to the constant threat of stagnation."[vi]
Charles Murnieks, Jeffery McMullen, and Melissa Cardon also
mention entrepreneurs being heroes (citing Campbell and Schumpeter). Using
surveys, they found that entrepreneurs experienced positive emotions (PE) when
they perceived that their self-identity as entrepreneurs matched that of
society or their environment. That is, if the entrepreneurs saw themselves as
risk-takers who enhance social welfare, and if the entrepreneurs thought that
society saw them that way as well, positive emotions were experienced.
Their empirical findings may support Allen and Lee's
contention that society should honor entrepreneurial accomplishments:
"challenging environments are part of
what makes a hero’s actions valiant. In a similar manner, we contend that
dynamic environments may play a key role in framing an entrepreneur’s actions
as courageous or innovative, because the individual is seen to act in the face
of uncertainty and turbulence. Stakeholders (such as mentors, family members,
or investors) who advise entrepreneurs should know and accentuate this point.
By providing reaffirming feedback in dynamic and challenging environments,
these stakeholders can elevate the PE experienced by the entrepreneur and
motivate them to continue on their journey. In essence, this strategy can help
separate the generation of PE from the success of the venture in some cases."[vii]
The "reaffirming
feedback" is a way to honor the entrepreneur which motivates them to
"continue on their journey."
The idea that entrepreneurs might be heroes is now
starting to reach the popular media. Barbara Haislip reported on how
storytelling, especially about the founders, can be a marketing tool for
businesses. She interviewed Angela Randolph of Babson College who said “Stories
about founders and new innovations are often in the form of a myth and follow
the hero’s journey.” Randolph then described the hero's journey as outlined in
Campbell. Telling the founding story about "the hero’s call to
action...pulls the audience in" if they can trigger "strong
emotions."[viii]
This question may be relevant now since entrepreneurship
may be in decline. Jeffrey Sparshott reported that “the share of private firms
less than a year old has dropped from more than 12 percent during much of the
1980s to only about 8 percent since 2010. In 2014, the most recent year of
data, the startup rate was the second-lowest on record, after 2010.”[ix]
Honoring and respecting the work of entrepreneurs might be a way to reverse
this trend.[x]
Also, historically, it may have only been when
entrepreneurs became respected that economic growth took off. Deirdre McCloskey
argues that what made the world so wealthy today, when average world income in
1800 was just $1 to $5 per day (adjusted for inflation) was a change in ideas:
"...in
Holland and then in England. The revolutions and reformations of Europe, 1517
to 1789, gave voice to ordinary people outside the bishops and aristocrats.
Europeans and then others came to admire entrepreneurs..."
It was a "Middle-Class
Deal" that gave entrepreneurs dignity and liberty to seek profit and
generate social welfare. This led to a flurry of inventions, innovations and
new institutions that made our modern world and therefore "the ordinary
people, and especially the very poor, were made much, much better off."
She even says "People had to start liking "creative destruction...""[xi]
In fact, one of her books is titled Bourgeois Dignity: Why Economics Can’t Explain the Modern World.
McCloskey writes
"that
the modern world was made not by the usual material causes, such as coal or
thrift or capital or exports or imperialism or good property rights or even
good science, all of which have been widespread in other cultures and at other
times."[xii]
McCloskey even credits "the
Kirznerian entrepreneur [for allowing her] to make progress on the puzzle of
economic growth." What is entrepreneurship? It is an "unhirable
factor" or "alertness" and "can't be something that can be
provided routinely, such as the services of banking or management. It must be
creative."[xiii]
Creativity comes from stepping outside the normal way of doing things,
"jumping over the edge and moving into the adventure" (see the
Campbell interview in the appendix). So the entrepreneur is just like the hero
in mythology.[xiv]
Appendix
Tape #1901: "Call of the Hero" with
Joseph Campbell interviewed by Michael Toms. New Dimensions Foundation audio
tape from a live interview on San
Francisco's radio station KQED. The following exchange was part of a
discussion of the question of: What is creativity?
Toms: In a sense it's the going for, the jumping
over the edge and moving into the adventure that really catalyzes the
creativity, isn't it?
Campbell: I would say so, you don't have
creativity otherwise.
Toms: Otherwise there's no fire, you're just following
somebody else's rules.
Campbell: Well, my wife is a dancer. She has had
dance companies for many, many years. I don't know whether I should talk about
this. But when the young people are really adventuring, it's amazing what guts
they have and what meager lives they can be living, and yet the richness of the
action in the studio. Then, you are going to have a concert season. They all
have to join a union. And as soon as they join a union, their character changes. (emphasis added, but Campbell changed the
tone of his voice) There are rules of how many hours a day you can rehearse.
There are certain rules of how many weeks of rehearsal you can have. They bring
this down like a sledgehammer on the whole thing. There are two mentalities.
There's the mentality of security, of money. And there's the mentality of open
risk.
Toms: In other societies we can look and see that
there are those that honor elders. In our society it seems much like the elders
are part of the main stream and there is a continual kind of wanting to turn
away from what the elders have to say, the way it is, the way to do it. The
union example is a typical one, where the authority, institution, namely the
union comes in and says this is the way it's done. And then one has to fall into
line or one has to find something else to do.
Campbell: That's right.
Toms: And it's like treating this dichotomy
between elders and the sons and daughters of the elders. How do you see that in
relationship to other cultures?
Campbell: This comes to the conflict of the art,
the creative art and economic security. I don't think I have seen it in other
cultures. The artist doesn't have to buck against quite the odds that he has to
buck against today.
Toms: The artist is honored in other cultures.
Campbell: He is honored and quickly honored. But
you might hit it off, something that really strikes the need and requirements
of the day. Then you've given your gift early. But basically it is a real risk.
I think that is so in any adventure, even in business, the man who has the idea
of a new kind of gift (emphasis
added) to society and he is willing to risk it (this is exactly what George
Gilder says in chapter three, "The Returns of Giving" in his book Wealth and Poverty). Then the workers
come in and claim they are the ones that did it. Then he (the entrepreneur)
can't afford to perform his performance. It's a grotesque conflict, I think
between the security and the creativity ideas. The entrepreneur is a creator;
he's running a risk.
Toms: Maybe in American capitalistic society the
entrepreneur is the creative hero in some sense.
Campbell:
Oh, I think he is, I mean the real one. Most people go into economic activities
not for risk but for security. You see what I mean. And the elder psychology
tends to take over.
[i]
Cyril Morong, "The Creative-Destroyers: Are Entrepreneurs Mythological
Heroes?" (Presented at the annual meetings of the Western Economic
Association, July), 1992, available at:
http://cyrilmorong.com/CreativeDestroyers.pdf
Cyril Morong, "The Calling of the
Entrepreneur," The New Leaders: The
Business Bulletin for Transformative Leadership, November/December 1992, p.
4, available at:
http://cyrilmorong.com/ENTREPRENEURshort.pdf
Cyril Morong, "Mythology, Joseph Campbell, and
the Socioeconomic Conflict,” The Journal
of Socio-Economics, Volume 23, No.4, Winter 1994, pp. 363-382, available
at:
http://cyrilmorong.com/MythCampbellSocioEconomic2.pdf
[ii] Wyn Wachhorst in Thomas
Alva Edison: An American Myth (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1981), pp.74-86,
uses Joseph Campbell's book The Hero With
a Thousand Faces to analyze part of Edison's early life, although Wachhorst
suggests that Edison might have been more trickster than hero. Wachhorst quotes
David McClelland from The Achieving
Society with: "Interestingly, David McClelland found that Hermes, the
trickster of the Greek pantheon, is the mythological type which best reflects
the "achievement personality [of entrepreneurs]."" Morong
(1992a) also mentions tricksters. The word entrepreneur does not appear in the
index of the Edison book. So Wachhorst probably did not look at any research on
entrepreneurs in general. He did not mention Schumpeter and creative
destruction, either. Wachhorst often compares Edison to Prometheus, suggesting
that using electricity is like stealing fire.
[iii]
Israel Kirzner, Perception, Opportunity, and Profit (The University of
Chicago Press, 1979), p. 163, 181.
From personal
correspondence with Israel Kirzner he writes "I should point out in my own
treatment of the entrepreneur, he is not seen as a "hero." Moreover,
in my own treatment pure luck is not seen as entrepreneurial. (but as the act
of deliberately putting oneself into a situation which one hopes will
prove lucky is entrepreneurial)." It is my contention that the best
way for a person to put themselves into a situation in which they will be lucky
is for them to follow Campbell's advice that is based on his analysis of the
hero's adventure. This is to follow your bliss, to listen to the wisdom of your
heart and do what you love, not what the social system would have you do. If
you follow your bliss, you are a hero. I believe that the most successful
entrepreneurs follow their bliss and are therefore heroes. Jeffery McMullen
(cited below) also mentions that entrepreneurs follow their bliss.
Joseph Schumpeter, The
Theory of Economic Development (New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction Books, 1983),
p. 923 lists three classes of motives for entrepreneurship: the will to found
private kingdom, the will to conquer, and the joy of creating. The first,
although seemingly only greedy, ranges, however, from "spiritual ambition
down to mere snobbery." The second was like a sporting event, with money
used to keep score, and not an end in itself. The entrepreneur of the third
class of motives is in it for the sake of "exercising one's energy and ingenuity"
and for the delight in venturing. All three classes of motives are
anti-hedonistic, with the third being the most so. This certainly makes it
plausible to see the entrepreneur as someone who follows his or her bliss.
[iv] Candace Allen and Dwight Lee, "The entrepreneur
as hero," Journal of Private
Enterprise, Volume 12, No. 1, Fall 1996, pp. 1–15.
[v] Dwight Lee and Candace Allen Smith, “The Entrepreneur on the Heroic Journey,” The
Freeman, Vol. 47 No. 4, April 1997, available at: https://fee.org/articles/the-entrepreneur-on-the-heroic-journey/
[vi] Jeffery McMullen, "Are we confounding heroism
and individualism? Entrepreneurs may not be lone rangers, but they are heroic
nonetheless," Business Horizons,
Volume 60, Issue 3, May–June
2017, pp. 257–259.
[vii] Charles Y. Murnieks, Jeffery S. McMullen, and Melissa
S. Cardon, "Does Congruence with an Entrepreneur Social Identity Encourage
Positive Emotion Under Environmental Dynamism?" Journal of Small Business Management, 27 February 2017,
doi:10.1111/jsbm.12335, abstract available at:
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jsbm.12335/abstract
[viii] Barbara Haislip, "Tell Me a Story," The Wall Street Journal, May 1, 2017,
page R8, available at:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/an-entrepreneurs-story-can-be-the-perfect-marketing-tool-1493604360
[ix] Jeffery Sparshott, "Sputtering Startups Weigh on
U.S. Economic Growth," The Wall
Street Journal, October 23, 2016,
available at:
https://www.wsj.com/articles/sputtering-startups-weigh-on-u-s-economic-growth-1477235874
[x] Allen and Lee (1996) mention that "during the
1980s almost 90 percent of all business characters on television were portrayed
as corrupt." It does not seem like there are many movies or TV programs
even now that show entrepreneurs in a positive light.
[xi] Deirdre McCloskey, "Liberty and Dignity Explain
the Modern World": An Essay Based on Bourgeois
Dignity: Why Economics Can't Explain the Modern World, November 2011,
available at: http://www.deirdremccloskey.com/articles/bd/briefBD.php.
[xii] Deirdre McCloskey, "Ideas, Not
"Capital," Enriched the World," March 19, 2016, available at:
https://fee.org/articles/ideas-not-capital-enriched-the-world/
[xiii] Deirdre McCloskey, "A Kirznerian Economic
History of the Modern World," June
17, 2011, available at: http://www.deirdremccloskey.com/editorials/kirzner.php
[xiv] McCloskey also writes that the growing freedom and
increasing respect for entrepreneurs "created more and more opportunities
for Kirznerian alertness." Furthermore "Austrian discovery and
creativity depends also on the other virtues, in particular on Courage and
Hope" and "A new rhetorical environment in the eighteenth century
encouraged (literally: "gave courage" to the hope of) entrepreneurs."
She does, however, see a weakness in that Kirzner does not consider the
audience of the entrepreneur, the customers and the rhetoric they use.
Sunday, September 17, 2017
New Book Attempts To Bring Economics And Literature Together
Adam Smith did not believe people are merely economic maximizers. Instead, we balance self-interest with humane sympathy for others. Deirdre N. McCloskey reviews ‘Cents and Sensibility’ by Gary Saul Morson and Morton Schapiro.
See Economics With a Human Face from The WSJ. Excerpts:
See Economics With a Human Face from The WSJ. Excerpts:
"economics—a hugely influential approach to studying human societies—isn’t worth all that much without first understanding what it means to be human.
Mr. Morson is a professor of Slavic literature at Northwestern University, and Mr. Schapiro teaches economics there"
"Economics, they argue, has been stripped down to a theory neglecting language and culture. At the same time, literary study has abandoned its responsibility to lead students to the best that has been thought and said. The humanities, Messrs. Morson and Schapiro contend, should acknowledge economics for worldly purposes. Yet for a truly human science the economists need literature, philosophy and history. Each discipline can supply what the other lacks."
"The real Smith observes that human beings summon qualities of sympathy balanced with their self-interest. People are not merely economic maximizers: They are ethical creatures from the get-go."
"Messrs. Morson and Schapiro advocate a fusion the economist Bart Wilson and the Nobelist Vernon Smith have recently dubbed “humanomics.” The humanities study categories, and the initial step of categorization is essential to any human inquiry."
"You can’t measure gross domestic product or unemployment without first saying what they are, qualitatively, as categories of interest to humans."
"There is no God-term telling us from the outside what categories humans care about. Economics, physics, biology, history—all need the first, humanistic, categorizing step."
Thursday, August 10, 2017
Is Storytelling Important For The Economy?
"It's the economy, stupid"-James Carville, strategist for Bill Clinton in the 1992 presidential campaign
"The human mind is a story processor, not a logic processor."-from the book The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt.
Wouldn't it be great if there was a blog that looked at the intersection of the economy and storytelling or mythology? Well, there is! See Dollars and Dragons.
Here is one example of how storytelling and economics come together. See Giving Your Brand Primal Power Through Storytelling by Nick Nanton & JW Dicks. Excerpt:
"The human mind is a story processor, not a logic processor."-from the book The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion by social psychologist Jonathan Haidt.
Wouldn't it be great if there was a blog that looked at the intersection of the economy and storytelling or mythology? Well, there is! See Dollars and Dragons.
Here is one example of how storytelling and economics come together. See Giving Your Brand Primal Power Through Storytelling by Nick Nanton & JW Dicks. Excerpt:
"At our agency, we make what we call “story-selling” an essential component of our branding efforts with our clients. We’ve seen firsthand that, when you create the proper story, you’ve done most of the heavy lifting required to build a successful brand.There is also a great book out there called The Storytelling Animal: How Stories Make Us Human by Jonathan Gottschall. Here is the review I wrote at Amazon:
The question, though, is why--why do stories have such “primal power” when it comes to influencing an audience?
It turns out there’s a perfectly good scientific explanation: Stories affect us on both on an incredibly deep intellectual and emotional level that we are just beginning to understand.
That quest began when scientists discovered that fictional stories affected the same region of the brain that reacts when we ourselves are engaged in real-life drama. Stories create a bonding empathy which causes us to strongly identify with the made-up protagonist, as if we were, in fact, that person. In other words, stories have such impact because our brains actually get a little mixed up as to what’s real and what’s not."
"If you liked "The Moral Molecule" by Paul Zak, "The Righteous Mind" by Jonathan Haidt or "The Power of Myth" by Joseph Campbell, you will probably like this book, too. It would be worthwhile if only for the anecdotes. The explanation about how a scientist proved that cats dream. Or that going to an opera greatly influenced Hitler. You want to keep reading. You never grow tired of it. How stories are a deeply inherent part of our nature is entertainingly explored. Stories affect business and economics because CEOs and brands need to tell a story. The role that evolution played in making stories important is explained. His theories and conclusions are supported by science. But it is still enjoyable. Gottschall himself is a good story teller. I love the line about stories being the flight simulators for life. The moral and socials role of stories are also explored. But stories are personal, too. We each have a story we tell ourselves. As Jung said, we should all try to discover what myth we are living by. Books like this should help us out on that quest."A related post is Economists Love Fables And Parables (Or, What Is The Essence Of Economic Analysis?)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)